Tuesday, December 31, 2013

A.D.H.D. experts re-evaluate study’s zeal for drugs...

Twenty years ago, more than a dozen leaders in child psychiatry received $11 million from the National Institute of Mental Health to study an important question facing families with children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: Is the best long-term treatment medication, behavioral therapy or both?

The widely publicized result was not only that medication like Ritalin or Adderall trounced behavioral therapy, but also that combining the two did little beyond what medication could do alone. The finding has become a pillar of pharmaceutical companies’ campaigns to market A.D.H.D. drugs, and is used by insurance companies and school systems to argue against therapies that are usually more expensive than pills.

But in retrospect, even some authors of the study — widely considered the most influential study ever on A.D.H.D. — worry that the results oversold the benefits of drugs, discouraging important home- and school-focused therapy and ultimately distorting the debate over the most effective (and cost-effective) treatments.

The study was structured to emphasize the reduction of impulsivity and inattention symptoms, for which medication is designed to deliver quick results, several of the researchers said in recent interviews. Less emphasis was placed on improving children’s longer-term academic and social skills, which behavioral therapy addresses by teaching children, parents and teachers to create less distracting and more organized learning environments.

 Recent papers have also cast doubt on whether medication’s benefits last as long as those from therapy. Full story...

Related posts:
  1. The selling of ADHD...
  2. Before his death, father of ADHD admitted it was a fictitious disease...
  3. Big Pharma invents yet another disease to sell deadly drugs: 'Shift Work Disorder'
  4. French ‘take 48 boxes of pills every year’
  5. How Big Pharma and the psychiatric establishment drugged up our kids...

No comments:

Post a Comment